|
The inability of quantum based methods to provide an exact
representation for complex chemical systems is
well
documented. Thus quantum based methods are prone to
inaccurate predictions due to the use of approximations,
assumptions, the diversity of factors involved,
intractable calculations, computational limitations,
indeterminacy and chaos. Santilli's
hadronic chemistry provides a further potential
source of inaccuracy due to the fact that it proposes
that the present quantum chemical theories require the
addition of a small correction factor for molecules with
2 or more electrons. These factors become even more
pronounced and inhibitive as the complexity of the
system increases. Randell Mills' hydrino species raises questions over the validity of quantum mechanics itself (The hydrogen atom revisited
R.L. Mills International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2000,25,1171-1183).
It is in the area of pericyclic chemistry and aromaticity/antiaromaticity
that quantum mechanics has seen it greatest growth
within chemistry.
Nobel prizes have been awarded for these methods;
namely the Woodward Hoffmann Conservation of Orbital
Symmetry, Fukui's Frontier Molecular Orbital Theory in
1981 and the ab initio and DFT methods in 1998.
Based on the above limitations of quantum based methods a new
theory of pericyclic chemistry and aromaticity/antiaromaticity
was developed and
published in 2006 in the
International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. It is
based on the chemical level of the reductional hierarchy
and is in line with the Robinson/Ingold electronic
theory of organic chemistry. As it is not based on the
physics level less factors are involved and thus there
is a lower probability of making inaccurate predictions
compared to quantum based methods.
This new chemical theory is called the
Cplex-isoelectronic theory.
A new electronic theory of pericyclic chemistry and aromaticity is proposed: The Cplex-isoelectronic theory. Consistent with Santilli's hadronic chemistry.
Cloonan MO. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2007, 32, 159-171.
Application of the Cplex-isoelectronic theory to electrocyclisations, sigmatropic rearrangements, cheletropic reactions and antiaromaticity: Consistent with Santilli's hadronic chemistry.
Cloonan MO. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2007, 32 , 3026-3039.
The assumptions of the Cplex-isoelectronic theory were deduced from
nucleophilic, radical addition, SN2 and SN2' reactions
and the anomeric effect. These assumptions were applied
to pericyclic reactions and aromaticity in line with
Complexity theory and is backed up by direct empirical
evidence from 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions
involving nitronates and by its ability to predict the
experimental data. The Cplex-isoelectronic theory makes
different predictions from the present quantum chemical
methods in some cases and the available empirical
evidence is consistent with these predictions.
The Cplex-isoelectronic is currently been developed for all areas
of pericyclic reactions and aromaticity/antiaromaticity.
Obtaining a link with hadronic chemistry and quantum
mechanics is for future study |